We Insure

PERSONAL INSURANCE

Proven solutions to drive your business forward.

Explore Business

We Insure MLS

Consultative coverage reviews and straight answers for Lady Lake households - without the usual price-only quoting.

We Insure MLS in Lady Lake
Address
13940 US Hwy 441, Blg 800, Lady Lake, FL 32159
Contact
Hours
M-F 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

We work with trusted insurance companies.

Progressive
Allstate
Nationwide
Travelers
Liberty Mutual
Geico

Home, Auto, Flood, and More

Common policy types reviewed for clients in Lady Lake and nearby communities

Home Insurance icon

Home Insurance

Protects your home, belongings, and liability.

Learn More
Auto Insurance icon

Auto Insurance

Coverage for cars, trucks, and daily drivers.

Learn More
Flood Insurance icon

Flood Insurance

Separate coverage not included in standard home policies.

Learn More
Condo Insurance icon

Condo Insurance

Coverage for your condo, personal property, and liability.

Learn More
RV Insurance icon

RV Insurance

Coverage for motorhomes and travel trailers.

Learn More
Renters Insurance icon

Renters Insurance

Protection for belongings and personal liability.

Learn More
Boat Insurance icon

Boat Insurance

Protection for boats and personal watercraft.

Learn More
Motorcycle Insurance icon

Motorcycle Insurance

Coverage for motorcycles.

Learn More

Ways We Help

1
Annual Policy Reviews
2
Multi-Carrier Quote Comparisons
3
New Homebuyer Consultations
4
Flood Zone Determinations

Ways To Meet

Phone
+1-352-758-8990
Hours
M-F 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Areas Served

Based in Lady Lake, serving clients across the greater Lady Lake area.

Downtown
North Side
South Side
East Side
West Side
Surrounding Areas

About the Owner

At We Insure MLS we know the foundation of everyrelationship is trust. I grew up in Orlando, FL, and spent my life engrained in thecommunity. Family is a big part of my life with 6 amazing kids and 4 wonderfulgrandkids. Prior to entering the world of insurance, I worked as a correctionsofficer for the state of Florida for 15 years. When I moved to Lady Lake about2 years ago a friend of mine convinced me to get my insurance license and it'sfit me ever since. I live and work within my community, and being only a fewmiles from the office I jump at the chance to help our clients!

How this office works

Owner started this office to give Lady Lake clients a more consultative insurance experience instead of a quick price-only conversation. The office focuses on: Taking time to ask better questions, understanding what matters to each household, and recommending coverage that actually fits the risk.

What stands out

Consultative coverage reviews instead of price-only quoting

Transparent when another solution is the better fit

Meet the Lady Lake Team

What homeowners in Lady Lake often miss

A common mistake is assuming flood risk only exists in high-risk zones. In the Lady Lake area, the better conversation is understanding the actual risk, the flood zone, and what the policy would do before a storm ever shows up.

What to review

Check flood, wind, and deductible details before storm season instead of waiting until a claim.

Review deductibles, water damage limits, and optional coverages before renewal so nothing important gets missed.

Rated ★★★★★ By Neighbors

"Cynthia everage is amazing! She worked so hard and fast to fix a huge mistake that happened during my closing and worked fast to get it resolved! She took all the stress off of me and i would recommend her to anyone"

Missy Torre

"Cynthia was the absolute best customer service representative we have ever dealt with. She went way beyond our expectations and was always researching the best policies for us. She was always in communication with us and kept us updated on policies that became available, even when we thought we had a pretty good deal. Her extensive research allowed us to compare different policies for our needs. She is the best and we would highly recommend her for additional insurance needs!! Thank you, Cynthia!!"

Larry Wygle

"I am very pleased with WE because if they don’t answer the phone, they call back shortly after. They respond to emails, even if they have the day off. The service that I am provided is top notch."

William Newlin

"Is there a 6 star, you need that for Cynthia Everage! We came to her practically crying because our Insurance got very complicated and we are almost on top of Closing date. Cyndi juggled all she was already doing, plus finding us a solution that worked for us and our lender. I honestly cannot say enough about her knowledge and expertise, she is absolutely fantastic!!"

Robert Rossiter

"I had a great experience purchasing Home Owners Insurance for our New Home in The Villages with Cynthia."

Joe Ingoglia

"Megan Khashman gave me the best rate and service, really makes the difference, she is very attentive and understanding"

Renata LeVasseur

"Megan was the most efficient in our time in such a quick transition during a difficult time. Such a refreshing experience she gave us with such ease. Thank you !"

Lynn Giotto Migliaccio

Local roots in Lady Lake

This office has deep Lady Lake roots, with team members who have lived and worked in the community for years. We understand the local market and the unique insurance needs of Lady Lake residents.

Community involvement includes:

Chamber and local business networking

Community charitable organizations

Local school and youth programs