We Insure - Preferred Agency
Consultative coverage reviews and straight answers for Athens households - without the usual price-only quoting.
We work with trusted insurance companies.
Home, Auto, Flood, and More
Common policy types reviewed for clients in Athens and nearby communities
Ways We Help
Ways To Meet
Find Us
Areas Served
Based in Athens, serving clients across the greater Athens area.
About the Owner
Jeremy Cansler Entrepreneur Real EstateDeveloper House Flipper Named Top 20 under40 Principal Broker of Silver Key Realty Jeremy Cansler is the Agency Owner of We Insure Preferred Agency. Jeremy started his agency to better serve his clients, bringing them great support and great products. Previously the President of Tri County Landlords Association.
Tabatha Barkley
· Resident of Athens Tennessee for over 27 years · Over 15 years in the insurance industry · Enjoys spending time with family and friends
Tabatha Barkley is the Managing Agent in Charge and has the experience and tools to assist each client with their insurance needs. We Insure believes in the Power of We. Our relationships with a multitude of top-rated insurance companies give our customers their own power to choose and the confidence of knowing they’re insured properly at premiums that work for them. We offer a different and better way to buy insurance—and our customers benefit. Purchasing insurance just got quicker and easier. Because we shop the top companies for our customers, they can relax and enjoy the benefits and the life they love. We make purchasing decisions hassle free. Our top-quality, experienced agents undergo extensive training. Our technologies and support allow our agents to focus 100 percent on serving our customers’ insurance-buying needs, searching top-rated carriers, evaluating coverage, identifying discounts, and giving customers the power of choice. We Insure is growing at remarkable speed. We know our success and growth results from taking exemplary care of our customers and agents.
How this office works
Owner started this office to give Athens clients a more consultative insurance experience instead of a quick price-only conversation. The office focuses on: Taking time to ask better questions, understanding what matters to each household, and recommending coverage that actually fits the risk.
What stands out
Consultative coverage reviews instead of price-only quoting
Transparent when another solution is the better fit
Meet the Athens Team
Tabatha Barkley
Managing Agent
Jeremy Cansler
Agency Owner
What homeowners in Athens often miss
A common mistake is assuming flood risk only exists in high-risk zones. In the Athens area, the better conversation is understanding the actual risk, the flood zone, and what the policy would do before a storm ever shows up.
What to review
Check flood, wind, and deductible details before storm season instead of waiting until a claim.
Review deductibles, water damage limits, and optional coverages before renewal so nothing important gets missed.
Rated ★★★★★ By Neighbors
Local roots in Athens
This office has deep Athens roots, with team members who have lived and worked in the community for years. We understand the local market and the unique insurance needs of Athens residents.
Community involvement includes:
Chamber and local business networking
Community charitable organizations
Local school and youth programs